Welcome to the book log. It contains various things.

BOOKS I’VE READ RECENTLY
Well, I haven’t read much in the way of children’s fiction lately. But I’ve read a lot of other books that I felt were very good for one reason or another. These include DRESDEN by Frederick Taylor, a pice of non-fiction about the terrible firestorm created there by allied bombers in February 1945, ANANSI BOYS, a hugely enjoyable fantasy with deep mythic roots by Neil Gaiman, and two Tim O’Brien books, his auto-biographical first book, IF I DIE IN A COMBAT ZONE, about his time as a conscript in Vietnam in 1969, and the surreal war story GOING AFTER CACCIATO, one of a number of his books that grew from his war experience. O’Brien is that rare sort of writer – and the concentration camp survivor and chemist Primo Levi is another good example - who can take a terrible personal experience and somehow use it to reflect on the nature of humanity, as opposed to inhumanity. The results are therefore ultimately life affirming, somehow, rather than simply depressing.

ON AGE RANGING
I also read THE BOOK THEIF by Markus Zusak, which I note is now being marketed as cross-over fiction, with an edition published for young people. As these editions tend to, it has a different front cover (not as good, I think). A sticker warns that the book is unsuitable for younger readers. This is probably true, in most cases. Perhaps not all, though. How can you generalise? The age-ranging of books has become something of an issue recently. Some publishers have decided to introduce an age suitability guide on the back of all children’s books. These publishers have put forward many arguments in favour of this move, backed up by market research aimed at parents and other adults who buy books for children. I don’t like the idea though. There’s something disappointing about saying that this book is for certain people only, those of this age or that, even if it’s only meant as a guide. It seems to deflate the idea of a book, by emphasising the fact that it’s a commodity to be codified and marketed. Some might say, yes, Tom, don’t be so soft, that’s all published books are. Book selling is a business and stories are just units to be shifted from a shelf. But somehow I can’t quite believe that. They seem to be more than that. There’s a website about this issue if you’re interested.
( www.notoagebanding.org )

By the way - Thanks to the commentator who wrote a note on my Cormack McCarthy review. I quite agree with you.